Short Term Rental Investment Properties for Sale in Staten Island, NY
or
Here are some other similar properties you might be interested in:
Listed for sale 1 day ago
$ 100,000
ROI
23.1
Cash Flow/m
92- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- - sft
198 Indian Church Rd, Buffalo, NY, 14210
Motivated Seller
Listed for sale 4 days ago
$ 100,000
ROI
23.4Cash Flow/m
101- 3 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 1306 sft
39 Cook St, Rochester, NY, 14620
Listed for sale 5 days ago
$ 100,000
ROI
23.2Cash Flow/m
96- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 650 sft
86-16 60th Avenue #4D, Flushing, NY, 11373
Listed for sale 5 days ago
$ 100,000
ROI
22.8Cash Flow/m
85- 1 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 750 sft
86-16 60th Avenue #3J, Elmhurst, NY, 11373
Listed for sale 7 days ago
$ 100,000
ROI
23.8Cash Flow/m
113- 1 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1554 sft
20 Tree Line Dr, Liverpool, NY, 13090
Fix & Flip
$ 100,000
ROI
33.6Cash Flow/m
385- 4 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 2642 sft
460 12th St, Niagara Falls, NY, 14303
$ 100,000
ROI
5.5Gross Rent Yield
9.3- - Bed
- 1 Bath
- 650 sft
485 East Lincoln Avenue #212, Mount Vernon, NY, 10552
$ 100,000
ROI
23.8Cash Flow/m
111- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1364 sft
11171 Miner Rd, West Winfield, NY, 13491
$ 100,000
ROI
-Cash Flow/m
-- 2 Bed
- 3 Bath
- 2387 sft
9600 Vermont View Rd, Machias, NY, 14101
Fix & Flip
$ 100,000
ROI
22.8Cash Flow/m
84- 2 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 1216 sft
6523 Wheeler Rd, Lockport, NY, 14094
Fix & Flip
$ 100,000
ROI
24.2Cash Flow/m
123- 2 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 750 sft
1017 Raymond Street, Schenectady, NY, 12308
$ 100,000
ROI
-Cash Flow/m
-- 6 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 2328 sft
1410 Hoag Rd, Ashville, NY, 14710
$ 100,000
ROI
24.3Cash Flow/m
126- 2 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 960 sft
5427 New York 9h Lot #16, Hudson, NY, 12534
$ 100,000
ROI
-Cash Flow/m
-- - Bed
- - Bath
- - sft
127 Harbour Town Lot 76, Bridgeport, NY, 13030
$ 100,000
ROI
23.1Cash Flow/m
94- 4 Bed
- - Bath
- 10 sft
43 Judson St, Albany, NY, 12206
$ 100,000
ROI
32.3Cash Flow/m
349- 4 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 2016 sft
139 Hope Ave, Syracuse, NY, 13205
$ 100,000
ROI
-Cash Flow/m
-- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1260 sft
6384 County Hwy 28, Long Eddy, NY, 12760
$ 100,000
ROI
24.0Cash Flow/m
118- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1650 sft
517 Deer St, Dunkirk, NY, 14048
$ 100,000
ROI
23.4Cash Flow/m
100- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1162 sft
10 Colleen Dr, Willseyville, NY, 13864
$ 100,000
ROI
22.9Cash Flow/m
86- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1824 sft
119 Hill Ave, Endicott, NY, 13760
$ 100,000
ROI
4.1Gross Rent Yield
9.6- 3 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1591 sft
40 Old Hickory Dr, Saratoga Springs, NY, 12866
$ 100,000
ROI
22.8Cash Flow/m
84- 2 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1830 sft
12022 Mortons Corners Rd, Springville, NY, 14141
$ 100,000
ROI
23.5Cash Flow/m
105- - Bed
- 1 Bath
- 575 sft
395 Westchester Avenue #6I, Port Chester, NY, 10573
$ 100,000
ROI
24.0Cash Flow/m
119- 3 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 1464 sft
202 Glebe St, Johnstown, NY, 12095
Why Invest in Staten Island, New York?
Short-term rentals in Staten Island face New York City's strict Local Law 18, limiting operations to registered hosted stays in primary residences with host present. Entire-unit rentals under 30 days are prohibited in Class A multifamily housing, reducing supply but creating niche opportunities for compliant investors. Average cap rates hover around 5-6% amid tight regulations, with rental yields at 4-5% for legal setups. Renter occupancy stands high at 45%, supported by steady appreciation of 3-4% annually. Cash flow averages $15k yearly for small compliant properties, appealing to hands-on operators navigating the rules.
7.2%
Avg. ROI
4.8%
Rental Yield
5.5%
Cap Rate
$15000/mo
Avg. Cash Flow
$2200/mo
Avg. Rent
3.5%
1Y Appreciation
Find Your Perfect Investment Property in Staten Island, New York
Explore investment opportunities by strategy, performance, or property type
