Save Search
Filters Applied
EditEdit Filters
Price: $300K - 500K
Monthly Cash Flow: $1 - $3k+
Home Type: Single Family
Under $500K Investment Properties for Sale in Buffalo, NY
Listed for sale today
$ 167,500
ROI
31.8
Cash Flow/m
560- 6 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 2780 sft
17 Lorraine Ave, Buffalo, NY, 14220
Currently Rented
$ 279,999
ROI
21.2Cash Flow/m
113- 5 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 2068 sft
427 Forest Ave, BUFFALO, NY, 14213
Listed for sale today
$ 242,500
ROI
25.9Cash Flow/m
416- 4 Bed
- 2 Bath
- 1320 sft
201 Royal Ave, Buffalo, NY, 14207
Currently Rented
Rental Income
Listed for sale today
$ 139,900
ROI
23.1Cash Flow/m
132- 3 Bed
- 1 Bath
- 1188 sft
25 Chadduck Ave, Buffalo, NY, 14207
Why Invest in Buffalo, New York?
Buffalo, NY offers strong investment opportunities in properties under $500k. Affordable entry points combined with steady rental demand make it ideal for cash flow-focused investors. The city's revitalization brings reliable appreciation potential around 4-5% annually. Renter-occupied housing exceeds 50%, supporting consistent yields. With cap rates averaging 7-8%, under-$500k properties deliver solid returns for value-add strategies.
9.2%
Avg. ROI
7.8%
Rental Yield
7.5%
Cap Rate
$420/mo
Avg. Cash Flow
$1250/mo
Avg. Rent
4.3%
1Y Appreciation
Frequently Asked Questions
Cap rates average 7-8% for single-family and small multifamily under $500k. Higher yields come from value-add opportunities in up-and-coming neighborhoods. Data reflects 2024-2025 market conditions from public housing reports.
Find Your Perfect Investment Property in Buffalo, New York
Explore investment opportunities by strategy, performance, or property type
