1 Valley Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964 | ROI: 8.8%

For Sale

Ziffy Mortgage

NMLS #2625701

Get Pre-Approved

Nearby investment properties with comparable rents

4 Bed
4 Bath
1600 sft

942 N Sea Rd, Southampton, NY, 11968

3 Bed
3 Bath
1500 sft

436 Scuttle Hole Rd, Water Mill, NY, 11976

3 Bed
2 Bath
2000 sft

33 Old Canoe Place Rd, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

3 Bed
2 Bath
2290 sft

2515 Sound Drive, Greenport, NY, 11944

Nearby investment properties with comparable prices

2 Bed
3 Bath
- sft

240 Three Mile Harbor Hc Rd, East Hampton, NY, 11937

2 Bed
3 Bath
2152 sft

56 Shinnecock Hills Rd, Southampton, NY, 11968

3 Bed
3 Bath
2000 sft

3500 Pine Neck Road, Southold, NY, 11971

5 Bed
3 Bath
- sft

1800 Sound Ave, Mattituck, NY, 11952

Ziffy AI Summary

A quick, investor-focused snapshot highlighting income strength, yield potential.

Key metrics	Value
Price	$399,900
Est. Rent	$3,200/mo
ROI	18%

Attractive rent-to-price ratio for income stability
Good fit for DSCR financing with healthy coverage

Explore more listings using simple english

Investment Highlights

Investment property for sale in Shelter Island at 1 Valley Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964 projects strong ROI of 8.8%. Rental yield 4.27%. With 5% annual appreciation, the property builds $649,262 in value over five years. Equity growth combined delivers a projected five-year ROI of 43.84%, translating into $333,789 in total cumulative return on $761,400 invested capital. You can finance this property with Ziffy Mortgage’s DSCR loan, which leverages the property’s income for qualification rather than your personal income.

Single Family

Built in 2006

0.70 Acres lot

$N/A/sqft

No HOA

Neighborhood Data

Neighborhood data shown for ZIP Code: 11964, Shelter Island, NY area.

Housing Distribution

Housing Statistics

Category	Value
Total HU (Housing Units)	1,130 (100%)
Owner Occupied HU	514 (45.5%)
Renter Occupied HU	157 (13.9%)
Vacant Housing Units	459 (40.6%)
Median Home Value	$939,167
Average Home Value	$1,071,080